Meet Hayley Murphy

REALTOR® | LIC# 2021004056

Hayley has lived most of her life in the central Columbus area. She is a graduate of Grove City HS and Bowling Green State University with many years of exemplary Customer Service and Sales experience. Prior to real estate, Hayley held a sales leadership position with Under Armour and now uses her experience to sell residential real estate, providing excellent service to build new and ongoing relationships with clients. In her free time, she enjoys working out, trying new recipes, and traveling!

What Clients Are Saying


“Hayley was a big help with finding the right place for our wants and needs. She took the time to listen to our goals and many questions. She is kind, understanding and most of all supportive. She never made us feel like we asked a bad question and was there for us every step of the process. Hayley was a joy to work with. Some day in the future if we sell the house, we hope to work with Hayley again.”

Jon C.


Hayley made the process of buying and selling a breeze, which is saying something in this market! She went above and beyond to answer our questions and to keep us informed every step of the way. We felt empowered to make a strong offer on our new home and to get our existing home market-ready while trusting that she had our best interests at heart. If you’re looking for a realtor who really listens, and is a perfect balance of friendly and professional, we would trust Hayley and the rest of her team at CRT again in a heartbeat!

Casey M. & Blake P.

Spread Kindness

The Nitzschke Team is dedicated to promoting kindness in the communities where we live and work. In that spirit, we’ll have a schedule of kindness initiatives throughout the year including hosting fundraising events and sponsoring nonprofits nominated by each agent.

Hayley nominated Children’s Miracle Network Hospitals, an organization dedicated to raising funds and awareness for 170 member hospitals that provide 32 million treatments each year to kids across the U.S. and Canada. If you’d like to support, you can donate to CMN Hospitals using the button below or contact us for more ways to get involved.

Get In Touch